Scarborough Football Club was one of the oldest in the country, having been formed in 1879 and celebrated its 125th anniversary on 2nd October 2004.  The club was formed by members of the local cricket team and originally played at the town's cricket ground in North Marine Road, but in 1898 moved to the Athletic Ground on Seamer Road which remained their home until the club's demise despite having changed its name to the McCain Stadium in 1988 under a pioneering sponsorship deal. 
 
The club first entered the FA Cup in 1887, and from 1898 played in the Northern League until the club turned professional and joined the Midland League in 1927. They were champions of this league in 1930 with a record number of points, and the following season reached the FA Cup Third Round where they lost 2-1 to top-division Grimsby Town in front of over 8,000 at the Athletic Ground.  Boro reached this same stage of the FA Cup again in 1937-38, where a home game against Luton Town set the all-time attendance record of 11,162 at the Athletic Ground.  The game finished 1-1, and Boro lost 5-1 in the replay. Local folklore states that the gate money from this game was put aboard the team coach but had become considerably less after visits to various hostelries on the way home!
 
Scarborough's Midland League performances entitled them to become founder-members of the new Northern Premier League in 1968 and set the scene the most successful era of Boro's history, with three F.A. Trophy triumphs at Wembley.  The trophy was won with a 2-1 win over Wigan Athletic in 1973, a 3-2 victory over Stafford Rangers in 1976 and a 2-1 win over Dagenham in 1977.  1975-76 saw the club reach the Third Round of the FA Cup for the third time in its history, with the 2-1 defeat to Malcolm Allison's Crystal Palace watched by over 8,000 at the Athletic Ground and millions more on BBC TV's "Match of the Day".  Two years later, victories over Rochdale and Crewe saw Boro reach the Third Round again, where a visit to Brighton ended in a 3-0 defeat watched by 23,748 at the Goldstone Ground.
 
Scarborough's Northern Premier League results were consistent enough for the club to be selected as founder-members of the new Alliance Premier League in 1979.  After seven seasons of generally finishing in mid-table, new manager Neil Warnock assembled a team which became champions of the re-named Vauxhall Conference in 1987 and was therefore promoted into the Football League under the brand-new system of automatic promotion.
 

The club's twelve-year period in the Football League was a mixture of highs and lows, with two appearances in the promotion play-offs but several seasons struggling near the bottom.  The real highlights came in the League Cup - a magnificent 3-2 victory over Chelsea after a 1-1 draw at Stamford Bridge in 1989, a 7-6 aggregate win over Preston North End followed by a 5-3 aggregate defeat to Southampton in 1991, and the best run of all in 1992-93 when victories over Bradford City, Coventry City and Plymouth Argyle brought the mighty Arsenal up to Yorkshire, where a solitary Nigel Winterburn goal gave the Gunners a narrow win. 
 
The season of 1998-99 brought the very first relegation in Scarborough's entire history, when they finished bottom of the Football League and dropped back down to the Conference.  Boro actually finished the season with 48 points from 46 games, but on the final day of the season Carlisle United gained a miraculous reprieve when on-loan goalkeeper Jimmy Glass went up for a corner deep into injury time and netted the winner which pushed Carlisle above Boro in the final league table.
 
Relegation from the Football League brought enormous financial worries for Boro.  A high turnover of unsuccessful chairmen/owners worsened the monetary problems, and the club was on the verge of folding on several occasions.  Season 2001-02 was particularly traumatic, but new chairman Malcolm Reynolds brought in Russell Slade as manager to oversee a quite dramatic turnaround at the club.  From bottom-of-the-table no-hopers at Christmas (14 points from 22 games), Boro put together a marvellous run which saw them climb to mid-table safety in the final placings.  Boro were 7th place in the league table in 2002-03, and the following season the league performances were overshadowed by a tremendous FA Cup run with wins over Doncaster Rovers, Port Vale and Southend United ending in the Fourth Round with a 1-0 defeat to Chelsea shown live on Sky TV.
 
With the departure of Russell Slade to Grimsby in the summer of 2004, player-coach Nick Henry stepped up to take charge of the team.  Neil Redfearn arrived at the club as his assistant.  Boro were on the fringes of the play-off zone for much of the 2004-05 season before fading away to finish in 13th position, but nevertheless went the whole season undefeated at home.
 
However season 2005-06 saw Boro finish bottom of the national division and relegated into Conference North, with the additional handicap of a ten-point penalty imposed by the Conference Board and a player embargo preventing the club from registering any new players.  In the end, these handicaps proved too much, and Boro were relegated for the third time in eight years.
 
Just as the fixtures were being compiled for the Northern Premier League season of 2007-08, a winding-up order was placed on the club and it went out of existence on 20th June 2007.